My Reseller Genie vs Soldbook: An Honest Comparison
My Reseller Genie and Soldbook both help resellers track profit. My Reseller Genie has more accounting depth. Soldbook focuses on true per-item profit, tax reporting, and a zero-risk integration model.
What My Reseller Genie does better
My Reseller Genie is a mature tool with more granular accounting capabilities. It has been around longer and has built out features that go deeper into the bookkeeping side of reselling.
- More detailed expense categorization and accounting features
- Longer track record in the reseller community
- Built-in inventory management with more fields
- Check myresellergenie.com for their full feature list and current pricing
What Soldbook does differently
- True profit formula: Sale price minus COGS minus platform fees minus payment fees minus shipping. Every item, every time, no manual math.
- Tax-Ready Report with 1099-K reconciliation: Schedule C-mapped totals that show the IRS how your gross breaks down to net -- specifically designed to prevent CP2000 notices
- Spreadsheet migration as the front door: Upload any .xlsx or .csv and auto-detect columns. Migrate your full history in under 10 minutes.
- No scraping, no extensions, ever: Official APIs and CSV imports only. Your eBay, Poshmark, and Mercari accounts are never at risk.
- Mobile-first quick-add: Log sourcing costs from the thrift store parking lot in under 10 seconds with offline sync
Side-by-side comparison
| Feature | My Reseller Genie | Soldbook |
|---|---|---|
| Per-item profit tracking | Yes | Yes (COGS + all fees + shipping) |
| Accounting depth | Deeper | Focused on reseller essentials |
| Schedule C tax report | Check their site | Yes (mapped to specific lines) |
| 1099-K reconciliation | Check their site | Yes (per-platform gross vs. net) |
| Spreadsheet import | Check their site | Full (auto-detect columns, any format) |
| Browser extension | Check their site | No (never) |
| Mobile quick-add with offline | Check their site | Yes (PWA with offline queue) |
| Pricing | Check myresellergenie.com | Free tier, $12/mo Pro, $29 one-time tax report |
Who should choose Soldbook?
If you want a focused tool that does three things really well -- true profit per item, tax-ready reporting, and effortless spreadsheet migration -- without ever putting your marketplace accounts at risk, Soldbook is built for that. If you need deeper accounting features, My Reseller Genie may be the better fit.
Know your true profit on every flip.
Try Soldbook freeRelated reading:
Informational only — not tax advice.